Can You Change Your Lawyer During a Personal Injury Lawsuit?

Have you ever been in the middle of a personal injury case and felt like your lawyer just wasn’t cutting it? Maybe they’re not communicating well, or perhaps their strategy seems off.  You’re not alone.  Many people question whether they can switch lawyers mid-case without jeopardizing their claim. Understanding your rights is crucial here. Yes,

Have you ever been in the middle of a personal injury case and felt like your lawyer just wasn’t cutting it? Maybe they’re not communicating well, or perhaps their strategy seems off. 

You’re not alone. 

Many people question whether they can switch lawyers mid-case without jeopardizing their claim.

Understanding your rights is crucial here. Yes, you can change your personal injury lawyer during a lawsuit, but it’s essential to consider the potential implications. The transition between your old lawyer and the new one needs careful handling to ensure continuity and protect your interests.

Remember, this isn’t a decision to take lightly. Your choice of legal representation can significantly impact the outcome of your case.

So, weigh up all the factors before making that move.

What Will Happen If I Change Lawyers In The Middle Of a Personal Injury Case?

A Pause in the Action

Switching up your legal team during a personal injury lawsuit could put the brakes on things for a bit. It’s like changing horses mid-race; there will be delays while the new jockey settles. The transition period can be a drag, with paperwork to transfer and case details to learn.

Don’t sweat it too much. Yes, there might be some lag time, but if you’ve decided a change is necessary, it’s probably worth the wait. 

After all, you want someone in your corner who’s got your back 100%, right?

Fresh Eyes, New Strategies

A new lawyer comes with a fresh perspective and potentially new strategies or approaches. Imagine getting a second opinion from another doctor—it can often lead to different solutions or treatments.

Your new lawyer may see things differently and devise an approach that wasn’t considered before. They might spot something missed or suggest an alternative way of handling things.

So, while switching lawyers might feel like hitting the reset button, sometimes that’s precisely what’s needed.

Why Do People Switch Lawyers in a Personal Injury Case?

Dissatisfaction with Current Lawyer

Let’s face it: not all lawyers are created equal. Some may have the gift of gab but lack the necessary skills to win a case. 

Others might be brilliant strategists but fail miserably at client communication. It’s no surprise that dissatisfaction with a lawyer’s performance or communication style is one of the top reasons people switch their legal representation in personal injury cases.

Imagine this: You’ve hired a lawyer who promised you the moon and stars, but several months into your case, you’re still waiting for that first court victory. Or worse, your lawyer has become as elusive as Bigfoot, leaving you in the dark about important updates on your case. 

Frustrating, isn’t it? That’s why many clients decide to ditch their current lawyer and search for someone else who can deliver better results or at least keep them informed.

Changes in Personal Circumstances

Life is like riding a roller coaster—full of ups and downs and unexpected twists and turns. Sometimes these changes can affect your personal injury lawsuit. 

Maybe you’ve moved to another city or state where your current lawyer isn’t licensed to practice law. Or perhaps, due to financial constraints or other personal issues, you prefer a different approach to handling your case.

In such scenarios, switching lawyers might be the best course of action. After all, it wouldn’t make sense to stick with a lawyer who can’t represent you because they’re not licensed in your new location or if they don’t align with your changed preferences.

Finding Better-Suited Legal Representation

Like shopping for the perfect pair of jeans, finding the right lawyer often involves trying out different options until you find one that fits just right. In some cases, people realize halfway through their lawsuit that another legal eagle is better suited to handle their case.

Maybe they offer more experience dealing with similar cases, or they have an impressive track record of securing favorable verdicts for their clients. Whatever the reason may be, discovering better-suited legal representation options often motivates individuals involved in personal injury lawsuits to switch lawyers.

How Could Changing Attorneys Affect My Case?

The Impact on Timeline and Strategy

The first thing to consider when you’re mulling over whether you can change your lawyer during a personal injury lawsuit is how it will affect the timeline and strategy of your case. 

Your current attorney has likely spent considerable time understanding the specifics of your situation, gathering evidence, and formulating a legal strategy. Introducing a new attorney into the mix could disrupt this process.

For instance, the new attorney will need time to get up to speed with all the details your prior attorney was handling. 

This could potentially slow down proceedings or even lead to changes in how your case is approached. It’s like swapping out the captain of a ship mid-journey – the new one needs time to understand the route and weather conditions before they can effectively steer.

Client-Lawyer Relationship Quality

Another factor that might be affected is the quality of your client-lawyer relationship. If you’re considering changing attorneys because you’re not satisfied with your current one, then bringing in a fresh face might improve things. 

You may find that you gel better with this new person, leading to more effective communication and ultimately a more positive experience.

On the flip side, if your relationship with your prior attorney was solid but other circumstances necessitated a change, building rapport with someone new might prove challenging. 

It’s akin to starting over in a romantic relationship – there are no guarantees that sparks will fly.

Financial Implications

Lastly, let’s talk about money, – specifically legal fees. Different attorneys have different fee structures; some might charge by the hour while others work on a contingency basis (i.e., they get paid only if you win). 

Switching from an hourly rate to contingency could potentially save you some cash upfront but may cost more in the event of a victory, as contingency fees usually constitute a substantial percentage of the settlement or award.

Moreover, remember that even after firing them, your prior attorney may still be entitled to compensation for their work via an ‘attorney lien’. This means they can recover legal fees from any settlement or judgment received.

So while yes, changing attorneys during a personal injury lawsuit is possible and sometimes beneficial depending on circumstances, it’s crucial to weigh these factors before making such a decision.

How Do I Go About Switching Lawyers in a Personal Injury Case?

Switching your auto accident attorney during a personal injury lawsuit might feel like switching horses mid-race. But hey, if the horse ain’t running fast enough, why not? 

Here’s how to do it.

The Steps Involved

  1. Write a Termination Letter: Just like breaking up with a bad date, you’ve got to let your current lawyer know it’s over. A written termination letter does the trick. It doesn’t have to be War and Peace; just keep it short and sweet.
  2. Sign Retainer with New Attorney: The next step is finding a new attorney who’s more your speed and signing on the dotted line of their retainer agreement.
  3. Transfer of Files: Finally, ask your old attorney to transfer all files related to your case to the new one. You want important documents to be noticed.

Timing is Everything

Changing attorneys might throw a wrench into things if you’re close to trial or an important negotiation session. So think twice before making that switch at crucial times.

Choosing Your Next Lawyer

Choosing your next auto accident attorney isn’t as simple as picking out socks from a drawer (unless you’re into designer socks). Here are some considerations:

  • Experience: You need someone who knows their way around personal injury law like the back of their hand.
  • Success Rate: Look for an attorney with a track record of winning cases similar to yours.
  • Communication Skills: You want someone who’ll keep you in the loop and explain legal jargon without making your head spin.

If changing lawyers has become too much of a hassle, make sure that you choose one that is good for you. Choosing Dyson Law, PLLC can help you avoid getting a lawyer who doesn’t have your interests at heart.

Our Boca Raton personal injury lawyers are always ready to help you bring justice to your side. We will never give up on you—we’re in this together from start to finish. 

Are There Any Reasons That You Can’t Switch Lawyers in the Middle of a Case?

Court Permission May Be Required

Switching lawyers mid-case is more complex than you might think. In some instances, you might need to get permission from the court. This is especially true if your case has already reached advanced stages. The court’s main concern is to avoid unnecessary delays that could potentially disrupt the course of justice.

For example, let’s say you’re knee-deep in a personal injury lawsuit, and you’ve decided to change your lawyer. The judge may be concerned that bringing a new attorney up to speed will cause significant delays in the proceedings.

The decision ultimately lies with the judge presiding over your case. They’ll weigh up whether allowing a change of attorney would cause too much disruption or not.

Contractual Obligations

Another potential roadblock when changing lawyers during a lawsuit is contractual obligations. When hiring an attorney, you typically sign an agreement outlining the terms of service and payment structures.

Some agreements may include clauses that prevent immediate termination without certain conditions being met first:

  • A minimum period of representation
  • Payment for services rendered so far
  • Satisfactory reasons for termination

Always read through your contract carefully before making any decisions about switching lawyers.

Strategic Considerations

Lastly, there are strategic reasons why it might not be advisable to switch attorneys mid-case:

  1. Loss of momentum: Your current lawyer is familiar with all aspects of your case.
  2. Time-consuming: It can take time for a new lawyer to catch up on all the details.
  3. Costly: Onboarding a new lawyer often means additional costs.
  4. Risking relationships: Judges, clerks, and other attorneys have established relationships that can impact cases subtly.

Where Does the Right to Switch Personal Injury Lawyers Come From?

Client Autonomy in Legal Ethics

First off, let’s dig into the roots of this. This all starts with the principle of client autonomy within legal ethics codes. It’s like choosing your own adventure book, but instead of a story, it’s your life. You are the one who gets to call the shots.

In legal lingo, this principle is often called the “client-lawyer relationship.” Sounds fancy, right? Well, it simply means that, as a client, you have the absolute right to hire or fire your lawyer at any case stage. 

The American Bar Association’s (ABA) Model Rules of Professional Conduct even enshrines this in Rule 1.16: Declining or Terminating Representation.

Constitutional Right to Counsel

The U.S. Constitution guarantees everyone the right to counsel in criminal cases under the Sixth Amendment. Now you might think: “But wait! I’m not a criminal!” True enough, but courts have interpreted this right broadly and extended it to civil cases like personal injury lawsuits too.

The key point here is that you’re not just stuck with any old lawyer; you can choose one who best represents your interests and needs.

Guidelines from State Bar Associations

Last but definitely not least are guidelines from state bar associations across America that uphold your right to switch lawyers during a personal injury lawsuit. These guidelines vary from state-to-state – think different flavors of ice cream – but they all share one common theme: protecting client rights.

For example:

  • In California, Rule 3-700 allows termination of representation by an attorney if they feel they cannot effectively represent their client.
  • On the other hand, New York’s Rules of Professional Conduct (Rule 1.16) dictate detailed procedures for withdrawing from representing a client.

How Will My Attorney’s Payment Change If I Change In The Middle Of The Case?

Changing lawyers during a personal injury lawsuit could also impact legal fees and payment arrangements. 

Here are a few possibilities:

  1. You might have to pay more: If your original lawyer was working on contingency (they get paid only if you win), they’ll still want their cut for the work they’ve done.
  2. You could end up paying less: If your new lawyer negotiates a lower fee than what you agreed with your previous attorney.
  3. It stays the same: Your new attorney agrees to honor the original fee agreement.

In any case, make sure you understand how this switch will affect your pocketbook so there are no nasty surprises down the line.

Owing Fees to Both Attorneys

When you switch attorneys mid-case, there’s a good chance you’ll end up owing fees to both your original attorney and your new one. Bummer, right? Your original attorney didn’t work for free after all! They’ve put time and effort into your case, and they expect payment for their services.

Now let’s say you’ve found another attorney who seems like a better fit for your case. Great! But here comes the twist: this new attorney may have a different billing structure than the first one.

Billing Structures Can Differ

Some attorneys charge by the hour, while others work on a contingency fee basis. What does that mean? Simply put, if an attorney works on a contingency fee basis, they only get paid if you win your case. They’ll take a percentage of the money awarded to you in court.

If both your original and new attorneys worked on contingency, then things can get even more complicated. Who gets what share of the pie? Well…

Contingency Fee Split

In most cases, the contingency fee will be split between the two attorneys based on how much work each one did on your case. Here’s how it typically goes down:

  1. The court determines what percentage of the award each lawyer should receive.
  2. This is usually based on how much work each lawyer did.
  3. If Lawyer A did 70% of the work, and Lawyer B did 30%; that’s how they’ll split the fee.

But remember that every situation is unique so these numbers can vary.

Navigating legal matters can sometimes feel like trying to solve an impossible puzzle, but don’t worry! Just keep in mind that switching lawyers mid-case might lead to additional costs due to differing payment structures or owing fees to both lawyers involved in your case.

Surely it makes sense now why understanding how changing lawyers could impact payments is crucial before making such decisions? It’s always best to stay informed so you don’t end up with any nasty surprises down the line!

Wrapping Up Your Legal Switcheroo

So, you’ve been through the wringer, got the low-down on changing lawyers mid-case, and you’re ready to move. It’s your right, after all. 

But remember, just like in chess, every move matters. Make sure it’s a well-thought-out decision because it could impact your case quickly.

Don’t forget about the moolah, either. Changing attorneys might shake up how payments work. So get clear on that before you take the plunge. And hey, if you’re still unsure or have unanswered questions, don’t sweat it! Reach out to a legal expert who can guide you through this maze.


Can I change my lawyer at any stage of my personal injury lawsuit?

Absolutely! You can switch your lawyer at any point during your personal injury lawsuit. However, remember that this decision should not be taken lightly, as it may affect the progression and outcome of your case.

Will changing my lawyer prolong my case?

It might. The new attorney will need some time to catch up with everything that has happened in your case so far, which could delay proceedings.

How does payment work if I change lawyers?

Typically, if you win the case, both the original and new attorney will share the contingency fee based on the amount of work each one did on your case.

Is there any situation where I cannot change my lawyer?

There are very few situations where you cannot change lawyers once they’ve been appointed – for instance, if a trial is underway or close to starting, then switching may be more difficult but not impossible.

Do I need to notify my current lawyer if I decide to switch?

Yes! If you decide to switch lawyers, it’s crucial (and polite) to inform your current attorney about this decision.

Peter A. Dyson, Esq


Peter Dyson is the managing partner of Dyson Law PLLC. Peter runs the day-to-day operations of the firm as well as actively litigates on behalf of clients...READ MORE

Skip to content