How Do Pre-Existing Conditions Impact Personal Injury Claims?

Pre-existing conditions can have a significant impact. Both plaintiffs and defendants must comprehend these conditions’ implications on their cases. Medical expenses can skyrocket when dealing with personal injury claims involving pre-existing conditions. Understanding how these conditions interact with new injuries is essential in determining liability and compensation. Navigating through such complexities can be challenging without

Pre-existing conditions can have a significant impact. Both plaintiffs and defendants must comprehend these conditions’ implications on their cases.

Medical expenses can skyrocket when dealing with personal injury claims involving pre-existing conditions. Understanding how these conditions interact with new injuries is essential in determining liability and compensation. Navigating through such complexities can be challenging without awareness of the potential hurdles.

By being aware of pre-existing conditions’ impact, you will be better equipped to handle your personal injury claim effectively. 

What is a Pre-Existing Condition?

A pre-existing condition refers to any medical condition or injury before the accident or incident. It can include both physical and mental health issues. 

Pre-existing conditions can significantly impact the outcome of your case. Insurance companies may argue that your injuries were not solely caused by the accident but were a result of your condition. They may try to minimize their liability by attributing your current injuries to prior conditions.

A pre-existing condition does not automatically disqualify you from pursuing a personal injury claim. However, it does complicate matters and requires careful consideration and documentation. 

You must prove that the accident aggravated or worsened your condition, resulting in additional pain, suffering, or medical expenses.

Before filing a personal injury claim, get all relevant information about your medical history and conditions. This includes obtaining medical records, doctor’s notes, diagnostic test results, and other documentation supporting your case.

Providing comprehensive evidence of how the accident has affected your pre-existing condition strengthens your claim.

Insurance companies often scrutinize pre-existing conditions closely during the claims process. They may request access to your medical records to evaluate whether similar symptoms or treatments were related to your current injuries before the accident occurred. 

It’s essential to be transparent about prior conditions and provide accurate information about their impact on your daily life.

In some cases, insurance adjusters may attempt to deny or undervalue claims by arguing that an individual’s injuries are primarily due to their existing conditions rather than the recent accident. 

But with proper legal representation and strong supporting evidence, you can overcome these challenges and seek fair compensation for the harm you have suffered.

Not all pre-existing conditions will significantly impact your personal injury claim. If your injuries are unrelated to your condition or the accident worsened your condition, you may still be eligible for compensation. 

Consulting with an experienced personal injury attorney can help you navigate the complexities of pre-existing conditions and ensure that your rights are protected.

What counts as a pre-existing injury or condition?

Understanding the impact of pre-existing conditions is crucial. These are any previous injuries, illnesses, or medical conditions that were present before the accident occurred. It’s important to note that even if a recent injury worsens a pre-existing condition, you may still be entitled to compensation.

Chronic ailments such as arthritis or back pain often fall into this category. These conditions can be ongoing and may have been aggravated by the accident. For example, if someone already had chronic back pain and got rear-ended in a car accident, their injury could be exacerbated.

But it’s not just major chronic ailments that count as pre-existing conditions. Even minor past injuries should be disclosed and considered when assessing their impact on your current personal injury claim. A prior sprained ankle or whiplash from years ago could affect your case.

Insurance companies and legal professionals often rely on medical records and expert opinions to determine whether something qualifies as a pre-existing condition. These documents provide valuable evidence of your health history and can help establish the extent to which your current injuries are related to prior ones.

It’s worth noting that insurance companies sometimes use pre-existing conditions as grounds for denying or reducing compensation. They may argue that your current injuries are not solely attributable to the accident but result from a combination of factors, including prior injuries or existing medical issues.

However, not letting this discourage you from pursuing your claim is essential. The law recognizes that accidents can exacerbate existing conditions or cause new injuries altogether. You may still have a valid claim as long as you can demonstrate that the accident played a role in worsening your condition or causing new harm.

Should You Disclose a Pre-Existing Condition?

Yes. Failing to do so can have serious consequences and may hinder your chances of receiving fair compensation.

One of the main reasons why disclosing a pre-existing condition is essential is that it helps avoid potential complications during the claim process. By informing the insurance companies and legal professionals about your medical history, you provide them with all the necessary information upfront. This transparency allows them to assess your case accurately and make informed decisions regarding your compensation.

Honesty about your medical history also significantly builds trust with insurance companies and legal professionals. When you are open about any pre-existing conditions, it demonstrates that you are forthcoming and trustworthy. Insurance adjusters are more likely to believe your account of the incident if they know you were honest about your health prior to the accident.

Furthermore, failing to disclose a pre-existing condition can harm your credibility throughout the entire personal injury claim process. Insurance companies often conduct thorough investigations into claimants’ medical records, looking for inconsistencies or undisclosed information. If they discover that you intentionally withheld information about a pre-existing condition, it could be seen as an attempt to deceive them. This can severely damage your credibility and jeopardize your chances of receiving fair compensation for your injuries.

It’s important to understand that not all pre-existing conditions will negatively impact your personal injury claim. In some cases, these conditions strengthen your case by showing how the accident exacerbated existing injuries or caused new ones. Regardless of whether the condition directly relates to the accident, disclosing it from the outset is crucial.

Can You Receive Compensation for a Pre-Existing Condition?

You may still be eligible for compensation even if you have a pre-existing condition aggravated by an accident or incident caused by someone else’s negligence. 

While having a pre-existing condition can complicate personal injury claims, it does not automatically disqualify you from seeking compensation. However, your compensation will depend on various factors, such as the severity of the aggravation and its impact on your overall health.

Seeking legal advice is crucial to determine if you have a valid claim and understand the potential compensation you may be entitled to. An experienced personal injury lawyer can assess your case, gather evidence, and guide you through the legal process. They will advocate for fair compensation on your behalf and protect your rights.

Insurance companies often try to minimize compensation based on pre-existing conditions. They may argue that your injuries were not solely caused by the accident but rather exacerbated by your medical condition. However, with proper legal representation, you can challenge these tactics and ensure that your pre-existing condition is considered when determining fair compensation.

It is important to gather relevant medical records and documentation to strengthen your claim and increase the likelihood of receiving fair compensation despite a pre-existing condition. This includes records detailing your medical history and any changes or exacerbations caused by the accident or incident.

Providing expert medical opinions supporting the link between the accident and the aggravation of your pre-existing condition can be beneficial. These opinions can help establish causation and demonstrate how the negligence of another party directly contributed to worsening your health.

When negotiating with insurance companies, presenting a strong case supported by compelling evidence is essential. Your personal injury lawyer will use their expertise to counter any attempts made by insurers to downplay or disregard your claim based on pre-existing conditions.

Why Should I Contact a Personal Injury Lawyer?

When dealing with pre-existing conditions in your claim, consulting with a personal injury lawyer is essential. A personal injury lawyer, such as Dyson Law, PLLC, has the expertise and knowledge to assess the impact of your pre-existing condition on your case and provide guidance accordingly. Our lawyers understand the complexities of personal injury law and can navigate the legal processes involved in pursuing a claim.

Insurance companies often try to downplay their significance or use them as an excuse to deny or minimize compensation. However, a skilled personal injury lawyer can counter these tactics and fight for your rights. They will gather all necessary evidence, including medical records and expert opinions, to build a strong case demonstrating how the accident aggravated your pre-existing condition or caused new injuries.

Navigating legal procedures can be overwhelming, especially when dealing with physical pain and emotional distress. A personal injury lawyer can handle all aspects of your case, allowing you to focus on your recovery. They will communicate with insurance companies, negotiate settlements, and ensure you receive fair compensation for new injuries and aggravations of pre-existing conditions.

One of the main advantages of hiring a personal injury lawyer is their ability to maximize your chances of receiving maximum compensation. They have extensive experience evaluating claims similar to yours and understanding how various factors come into play when determining settlement amounts. By leveraging their negotiation skills, they can advocate for your best interests and strive for an outcome that reflects the true extent of your damages.

In addition to negotiating fair settlements, personal injury lawyers are prepared to take cases to trial if necessary. This willingness sends a powerful message to insurance companies that you are serious about seeking justice for your injuries. It pressures them to offer reasonable settlements rather than risk facing litigation in court.

See a doctor before filing your personal injury claim.

It is crucial to prioritize seeking medical attention promptly after an accident or incident, regardless of any pre-existing conditions you may have. 

By seeing a doctor, you ensure that all injuries, including any aggravation of pre-existing conditions, are properly documented. This step is vital in establishing the causation between the accident or incident and any exacerbation of your existing health issues.

Medical records serve as essential evidence. They provide concrete documentation of your injuries and their connection to the accident or incident. Insurance adjusters and courts heavily rely on these records to assess the damages and determine compensation for the injured party.

Delaying medical treatment can significantly weaken your case. Insurance companies often seize opportunities to argue that other factors caused or contributed to your condition. 

Immediately seeking medical attention strengthens your argument by demonstrating that the accident directly resulted in your injuries.

In some instances, insurance adjusters may attempt to downplay the severity of your injuries by claiming they were pre-existing conditions unrelated to the accident. However, with proper documentation from doctors who can attest to any aggravation caused by the incident, you can counter such arguments effectively.

In addition to supporting causation arguments, medical records also help establish negligence on behalf of the defendant. They demonstrate how their actions or failure to act led to harm and highlight their responsibility for compensating you for damages incurred.

Moreover, timely medical treatment ensures that potential complications from untreated injuries are minimized or avoided. Failure to address these complications promptly could lead to prolonged suffering and increased medical bills and recovery time.

By visiting a doctor promptly following an accident or incident, you protect your health and legal rights. Your physician will conduct thorough examinations and order relevant tests based on their expertise. They will provide accurate diagnoses and recommend appropriate treatments tailored to your situation.

Remember that you must talk with your doctor about any pre-existing conditions. This information allows them to better evaluate the impact of the accident or incident on your overall health and well-being.

Be honest about your pre-existing condition.

One of the most important aspects is being honest about any pre-existing conditions you may have. This honesty should extend to all parties involved in your case, including doctors, lawyers, and insurance representatives. Failing to disclose or misrepresent information about previous injuries or illnesses can have serious consequences and harm the credibility of your claim.

Honesty is crucial because it allows professionals evaluating and settling claims to accurately assess the impact of the accident or incident on both new injuries and existing conditions. By providing full disclosure, you give them all the necessary information to make an informed decision about your case.

You risk losing trust throughout the claims process by hiding or downplaying a pre-existing condition. Insurance companies and legal professionals rely on transparency when evaluating claims. If they discover that you were not forthcoming about a pre-existing condition, it could lead to skepticism regarding the validity of your claim.

To understand why honesty matters so much in personal injury claims involving pre-existing conditions, let’s consider a few scenarios:

  1. Accurate assessment: Suppose you had a history of back problems before a car accident. If you fail to disclose this information, doctors treating your injuries may attribute all symptoms solely to the accident. However, if they know about your pre-existing condition, they can better determine which symptoms are new and directly related to the accident.
  2. Proper compensation: By honestly disclosing information, lawyers handling your case can factor in any potential aggravation of that previous injury caused by the current incident when seeking appropriate compensation for medical expenses or pain and suffering.
  3. Credibility: When discussing your case with insurance representatives or testifying in court, being forthright about your pre-existing conditions helps maintain credibility. It shows that you are not trying to hide anything and reinforces the validity of your claim.

Remember, personal injury claims seek fair compensation for the harm caused by someone else’s actions. Being honest about your pre-existing conditions ensures that all parties involved can make informed decisions based on accurate information. Transparency builds trust and increases the chances of a successful outcome for your claim. 

The Eggshell Plaintiff Rule: How it Affects Your Personal Injury Claim

According to this guideline, if someone causes harm, they can be responsible for all damages, even if the injured person had a health issue or previous injury that made them more vulnerable than a typically healthy individual.

In other words, if you have a pre-existing condition and someone else’s actions aggravate or worsen that condition, the person responsible for your injury is still liable for the consequences.

This rule ensures that individuals with pre-existing conditions are not unfairly penalized when seeking compensation for injuries caused by someone else’s negligence. 

It recognizes that everyone has different vulnerabilities and should be held accountable for their actions, regardless of the victim’s prior health status. 

Understanding the implications of the Eggshell Plaintiff Rule can significantly strengthen your personal injury claim and protect your rights. By highlighting how the defendant’s actions aggravated or worsened your pre-existing condition, you can demonstrate their responsibility for your current state.

To successfully utilize this legal principle in your personal injury claim:

  1. Gather evidence: Collect all relevant medical records and documentation related to your pre-existing condition and any worsening caused by the incident.
  2. Consult with an attorney: Seek professional legal advice from an experienced personal injury lawyer who understands how to apply the Eggshell Skull Rule to your case effectively.
  3. Document the impact: Keep a detailed record of how the defendant’s actions have affected your daily life, including any limitations, pain, or emotional distress you experience.
  4. Obtain expert opinions: If necessary, consult medical experts who can provide testimony supporting the connection between the incident and the aggravation of your pre-existing condition.
  5. Calculate damages: Work with your attorney to determine an appropriate compensation amount considering the exacerbation of your pre-existing condition and any additional medical expenses incurred.


Honesty is key. Being transparent about your medical history gives you the best chance of receiving fair compensation. Seeking a lawyer can help your case and make it easier for you to navigate it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I still file a personal injury claim if I have a pre-existing condition?

Yes, you can still file a personal injury claim even if you have a pre-existing condition. You must disclose this information and provide accurate medical records to support your case.

Will my pre-existing condition affect the amount of compensation I receive?

The impact of a pre-existing condition on your compensation will depend on various factors, such as the extent to which it was aggravated or worsened by the incident. Consulting with a personal injury lawyer can help determine how your pre-existing condition may affect your claim.

What if I didn't know about my pre-existing condition before the incident?

If you were unaware of your pre-existing condition before the incident, it is still essential to disclose it during the claims process. Failing to do so could potentially harm your case if discovered later.

Can I receive compensation for the aggravation of a pre-existing condition?

You may be eligible for compensation if an incident aggravates or worsens a pre-existing condition. However, proving causation and establishing the extent of aggravation can be complex, so consulting with a personal injury lawyer is advisable.

How long do I have to file a personal injury claim involving a pre-existing condition?

The statute of limitations for filing a personal injury claim varies depending on the jurisdiction. It is crucial to consult with a personal injury lawyer promptly after an incident involving a pre-existing condition to ensure you meet all necessary deadlines.

Peter A. Dyson, Esq


Peter Dyson is the managing partner of Dyson Law PLLC. Peter runs the day-to-day operations of the firm as well as actively litigates on behalf of clients...READ MORE

Skip to content